Skip to main content

Main Area

Main

Mistakes from the 50 best movies of all time

Mistakes from the 50 best movies of all time
1/Lucasfilm

Mistakes from the 50 best movies of all time

Hollywood movie-making takes time, money, cooperation, careful planning, and a painstaking knack for detail. But even the most meticulous preparations sometimes can't spare a film from its share of goofs and mistakes to the delight (or chagrin) of observant viewers. The majority of these goofs take the form of simple continuity errors. For example, a glass might be full in one shot and empty in the very next. Other mistakes appear by way of historical misfires, major plot holes, visible camera equipment, or crew members getting caught in a shot.

And every now and then, the annals of cinema are graced with a goof of epic proportions: For example, white cars can be seen in the background during a battle scene in “Braveheart.” Since even the world's greatest films are prone to the occasional flub, Stacker is embracing the imperfections by listing mistakes from the 50 best movies of all time. To determine the rankings, Stacker derived a score based on equally weighted IMDb ratings and Metacritic scores. Only English-language movies released in the United States were considered for the list, and each film needed at least 20,000 votes on IMDb to qualify. If the movie didn't have a Metascore, it was not included.

Check out mistakes in the 50 best movies of all time.

You may also like: 100 best movies of the 21st century, according to critics

#50. The Wild Bunch
2/Warner Bros.

#50. The Wild Bunch

There are around a half dozen big goofs in the period Western “The Wild Bunch.” A few of those have to do with the year the movie takes place (1913) and items that weren't yet invented at that time, such as a Browning model 1917 machine gun—and Coffer's Model 1903/A3 bolt-action rifle used in the bank shootout scene (the /A3 variant wasn't made until the early 1940s). There are also a number of blips in style; namely, women wearing what is obviously 1960s-style eye makeup and hairdos.

#49. Beauty and the Beast
3/Walt Disney Pictures

#49. Beauty and the Beast

Long before she crossed paths with magic dinnerware, Belle was apparently in possession of a magic front door. In one scene, the door to her home is located atop some stairs and facing a porch. But when she tosses Gaston out in a later scene, the door opens on the ground level and faces a small pool of mud. It also swings outward and inward.

#48. The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance
4/Paramount Pictures

#48. The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance

This classic drama from John Ford tackles themes of justice, law, and order. At the heart of the film is Ransom Stoddard (James Stewart), a lawyer and eventual politician who incorrectly teaches his students that the Declaration of Independence is the supreme law of the land. Presumably he figured out that the famous document contains no actual laws before he became a senator.

#47. There Will Be Blood
5/Paramount Vantage

#47. There Will Be Blood

In the final act of this gripping saga, Eli Sunday (Paul Dano) chugs his first drink and doesn't finish his second. In the next shot, however, both glasses are empty.

#46. Toy Story 3
6/Walt Disney Pictures

#46. Toy Story 3

Much of "Toy Story 3" takes place at a hostile daycare center, where an evil bear named Lotso runs the show. On the toys' first night, there are no trucks patrolling the hallways, and the monkey doesn't sound the alarm when he sees that Buzz escaped. Later, it's revealed that both the trucks and the alarm are routine security measures that operate nightly. 

#45. It's a Wonderful Life
7/Liberty Films

#45. It's a Wonderful Life

One of the most iconic scenes in this holiday favorite finds a bunch of partygoers jumping into a pool. A close look reveals the same character jumping in twice. This one was most likely a continuity error.

#44. The Philadelphia Story
8/Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer

#44. The Philadelphia Story

Audio synchronicity wasn't exactly a perfected art form when "The Philadelphia Story" came out in 1940. In the film, Liz (Ruth Hussey) repeatedly utters the phrase "just that" during an exchange with Mike (James Stewart). As they head toward an office, she says the phrase one last time, but no sound emerges.

#43. A Streetcar Named Desire
9/Charles K. Feldman Group

#43. A Streetcar Named Desire

Marlon Brando is widely considered one of the greatest film actors of all time, but that doesn't mean he was always the most prepared. During a poker scene in this 1951 drama, Brando's Stanley Kowalski can be seen mimicking Stella's lines with his lips as if trying to recall the script from memory.

#42. Rosemary's Baby
10/William Castle Productions

#42. Rosemary's Baby

In this legendary horror flick, director Roman Polanski uses the clicking of a bedroom clock to mark the passage of time during Rosemary's dream. During a later scene, it's revealed that the very same clock is plugged into the wall. That means it's an electric clock—and electric clocks don't tick.

#41. Ratatouille
11/Pixar Animation Studios

#41. Ratatouille

It's said that the team behind this acclaimed Pixar movie embarked on several research trips to get a better understanding of French cuisine. Yet the film refers to a majority of herbs—such as rosemary, oregano, thyme, basil—as spices. 

#40. Inside Out
12/Pixar Animation Studios

#40. Inside Out

Despite its fictional portrayal of human emotions, this animated smash hit from Pixar clearly strived for psychological and biological accuracy. Had it wanted to present things as they really are, however, it would have shown the world in limited color when depicting it through newborn Riley's eyes. That's because babies don't develop the ability to see the color spectrum until they're about 5 months old.

#39. Star Wars: Episode IV - A New Hope
13/Lucasfilm

#39. Star Wars: Episode IV - A New Hope

One of cinema's most iconic films appropriately contains a mishap for the ages. It occurs when three stormtroopers are walking down a hall, and one of them nails his head on a lowering door. 

#38. Goodfellas
14/Warner Bros.

#38. Goodfellas

Offering a bevy of iconic characters and sequences, Martin Scorsese's gangster epic is likewise filled to the brim with factual errors, exposed equipment, and other goofs. Perhaps the most glaring mistake comes during a scene where Jimmy (Robert De Niro) wraps a phone cord around Morrie's neck in the back of the wig shop. The phone is clearly off the hook, yet it starts to ring.

#37. The Adventures of Robin Hood
15/Warner Bros.

#37. The Adventures of Robin Hood

This celebrated adventure flick takes place in the year 1191. Yet when one of Robin Hood's merry men dismounts a horse to help a friend, there's a car in the background. Unless that car's a DeLorean, someone has some explaining to do.

#36. The Grapes of Wrath
16/Twentieth Century Fox

#36. The Grapes of Wrath

In the book upon which this 1940 film was based, slow-witted Noah Joad runs away from home after becoming a burden to his family. In the film version, Noah (Frank Sully) spontaneously disappears with no explanation at all and is simply never heard from again. 

#35. The Maltese Falcon
17/Warner Bros.

#35. The Maltese Falcon

At the center of this hard-boiled mystery is a priceless statuette known as the Maltese Falcon. Made of a precious metal, the falcon would weigh at least 35 to 45 pounds in real life; however, at least two characters in the film pick up the falcon or put it down as if it weighs less than a small sack of flour.

#34. 12 Years a Slave
18/Regency Enterprises

#34. 12 Years a Slave

To depict the true horrors of slavery, director Steve McQueen took some liberties while adapting Solomon Northup's now-famous memoir. But creative license becomes a historical goof when the main character is asked where he became an expert in ”terraforming." That particular word wouldn't be invented for another 100 years.

#33. The Apartment
19/United Artists // Wikimedia Commons

#33. The Apartment

Billy Wilder's 1960 classic was brilliant in many ways, but its continuity issues were rampant. In the opening sequence, C.C. Baxter's (Jack Lemmon) narration tells the audience this is 1959—which means Christmas that year was on a Friday. Yet people come into work the two days after Christmas, when it would have been a weekend. Similarly, Baxter states the date at the start of the film is Nov. 1, which was a Sunday in 1959. But Baxter tells a coworker about a Halloween party the night before, which would have actually been a Saturday; the men would not have been in the office the next day.

#32. Taxi Driver
20/Columbia Pictures Corporation

#32. Taxi Driver

Spoiler alert: toward the end of "Taxi Driver," Travis Bickle (Robert De Niro) goes on a murderous rampage and gets shot in the neck. Makeup artist Dick Smith would later confirm in a documentary that when De Niro presses his hand against the wound, he reveals wrinkles in his bald skin cap.

#31. Saving Private Ryan
21/DreamWorks

#31. Saving Private Ryan

In this award-winning World War II film, soldiers try to save a medic after he gets shot in the stomach. Look near the medic's neck as the soldiers tear at his shirt and one can briefly spot the perimeter of a fake stomach. Consider it a thankful reminder that the brutally graphic scene is Hollywood magic and not real footage.

#30. Double Indemnity
22/Paramount Pictures

#30. Double Indemnity

In this classic film noir, insurance salesman Walter Neff (Fred MacMurray) gets lured into a duplicitous scheme by Phyllis Dietrichson (Barbara Stanwyck). Neff is supposed to be a bachelor, but MacMurray's real-life wedding ring can be spotted throughout the film. 

#29. Toy Story
23/Pixar Animation Studios

#29. Toy Story

A major plot point in Pixar's breakout hit is that Andy and his family are moving in a matter of days. But once Buzz becomes Andy's favorite toy, Andy's mom changes the bedroom wallpaper from a cowboy theme to a spaceman theme. Couldn't that have waited until they arrived at the new house?

#28. Boyhood
24/IFC Productions

#28. Boyhood

Famously shot over the course of 12 years, Richard Linklater's film follows young Mason (Ellar Coltrane) as he moves repeatedly from one town to the next. Before moving to Houston, there's a bumper sticker on his mom's car that reads: "Atherton Elementary Honor Student On Board." Atherton Elementary is actually located in Houston. 

#27. The Night of the Hunter
25/Paul Gregory Productions

#27. The Night of the Hunter

The entire premise of this noirish drama is more or less built on an impossible scenario. While in prison for a misdemeanor, Harry Powell (Robert Mitchum) shares a cell with a death row inmate, who mutters in his sleep about a stolen fortune. In real life, a man charged with a misdemeanor wouldn't be in the same facility as a death row inmate, let alone the same cell.

#26. Touch of Evil
26/Universal International Pictures

#26. Touch of Evil

This noirish thriller from Orson Welles opens with one of the most emblematic long shots in cinematic history. At the beginning of the famously extended sequence, a crew member is briefly visible in the upper lefthand corner of the screen. Of course, most eyes are on the bomb being placed in the trunk of a car.

#25. Gone with the Wind
27/Selznick International Pictures

#25. Gone with the Wind

It might be the highest-grossing film of all time (when adjusted for inflation), but that doesn't mean "Gone with the Wind" isn't packed with its own share of mistakes. For instance, the film takes place before the invention of the lightbulb, yet a number of lamps in the film have either a cord or bulb.

#24. Some Like It Hot
28/The Mirisch Corporation

#24. Some Like It Hot

This 1959 comedy classic set in 1929 delivers an array of choice musical numbers, including Marilyn Monroe's rendition of "I'm Thru With Love." That particular song didn't come out until the 1930s. 

#23. Wall-E
29/Walt Disney Pictures

#23. Wall-E

The film about an anthropomorphized trash compactor grossed $223.8 million in the U.S. and Canada, and $309.5 million around the world. But at its most basic, Wall-E's functionality as a Waste Allocation Load Lifter Earth-class just doesn't make sense. When he puts trash into his main chamber to condense it, the trash he expels has the same volume as what he put in.

#22. Apocalypse Now
30/Zoetrope Studios

#22. Apocalypse Now

Making this Vietnam War epic was an absolute nightmare for director Francis Ford Coppola, so it's no surprise that the film contains a reported 395 errors. During one of the movie's most iconic scenes, "Ride of the Valkyries" plays through aerial speakers as military helicopters approach a small village. A closer look reveals that the reel-to-reel tape never touches the playback head.

#21. The Wizard of Oz
31/Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer

#21. The Wizard of Oz

When Dorothy and the Scarecrow meet the Tin Man for the first time, they apply oil to his rusty joints so that he can move. There's just one problem: tin doesn't rust. While legions of fans will argue that the Tin Man probably contained metal parts, or that ”rust“ is being used colloquially in this particular instance, the scene nevertheless endures as a famous flub.

#20. Notorious
32/RKO Radio Pictures

#20. Notorious

The brooding Hitchcock film centering on a government agent (Cary Grant) who sends Alicia (Ingrid Bergman) the daughter of a German war criminal, to go undercover and spy on a group of Nazis in South America has its share of kerfuffles outside the intricate plotline. In one scene, as Alicia realizes she's being poisoned, the cup she just drank reappears full.

#19. The Treasure of the Sierra Madre
33/Warner Bros.

#19. The Treasure of the Sierra Madre

True to its name, this John Huston adventure takes place in the Sierra Madre mountains of Mexico. But if that's the case, then why is there an Australian kookaburra making noises in the background? 

#18. The Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Ring
34/New Line Cinema

#18. The Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Ring

If there's one thing Peter Jackson's ”Lord of the Rings“ trilogy shouldn't screw up, it's the placement of the precious ring itself. Yet in this first installment, Frodo slips the ring on his middle finger to become invisible and then has the ring on his index finger just a few moments later.

#17. The Godfather: Part II
35/Paramount Pictures

#17. The Godfather: Part II

Director Francis Ford Coppola made an intentional cameo in "Apocalypse Now," but his appearance in "The Godfather: Part II" was purely accidental. As young Vito Corleone (Robert De Niro) drives down the street, Coppola's reflection briefly appears in a car window. 

#16. Sweet Smell of Success
36/Norma Productions

#16. Sweet Smell of Success

This acclaimed drama depicts the fraught relationship between a columnist and press agent, so one might expect it to portray newspapers with a relative degree of authenticity. On the contrary, the film repeats certain paragraphs over and over when Sidney Falco (Tony Curtis) peruses J.J. Hunsecker's (Burt Lancaster) Broadway column.

#15. All About Eve
37/Twentieth Century Fox

#15. All About Eve

This timeless drama deals with the ins and outs of show business, so it's almost meta when Addison (George Sanders) slaps Eve and her head turns the wrong way. Actress Anne Baxter's minor blunder is otherwise known as a "stage" slap.

#14. North by Northwest
38/Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer

#14. North by Northwest

The movie that arguably spawned the modern action genre also touts one of cinema's most well-known goofs. It goes down during a climactic scene inside the Mount Rushmore cafeteria, where Eve Kendall (Eva Marie Saint) pulls out a gun and prepares to shoot Roger Thornhill (Cary Grant). Before the gunshot rings out, a young boy in the background is already covering his ears.

#13. Dr. Strangelove or: How I Learned to Stop Worrying and Love the Bomb
39/Columbia Pictures Corporation

#13. Dr. Strangelove or: How I Learned to Stop Worrying and Love the Bomb

Even renowned perfectionist Stanley Kubrick was prone to the occasional mistake, including grammatical errors. During the opening credits sequence in this dark comedy, the text reads, "Base on the book Red Alert by Peter George." The words "fictitious" and "occurrence" are also misspelled during the same credits sequence.

#12. Modern Times
40/Charles Chaplin Productions

#12. Modern Times

King of slapstick comedy Charlie Chaplin resorted to a variety of cinematic tricks while executing this brilliant satire. When his character famously emerges from the giant machine, for instance, the footage is played backward. If not for the men behind Chaplin hammering in reverse, the audience would be none the wiser.

#11. Singin' in the Rain
41/Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer

#11. Singin' in the Rain

The most famous scene in this acclaimed musical appropriately features Gene Kelly singing and tap-dancing in the rain. Keen observers might notice that the sound of tapping doesn't always match up to the movements of his feet. In fact, listen closely enough and one might hear the sound of tapping even after Kelly's stopped dancing altogether.

#10. Psycho
42/Shamley Productions

#10. Psycho

Hitchcock's famous shower scene endures as a work of art unto itself, albeit one with a minor mistake. As Janet Leigh's character lies dead on the floor, her eyes are contracted when they're supposed to be dilated. After learning of the error, Hitchcock reportedly consulted with a handful of ophthalmologists, who recommended that he use belladonna eye drops when depicting murder victims.

#9. Schindler's List
43/Universal Pictures

#9. Schindler's List

Steven Spielberg was striving for authenticity when crafting this award-winning drama, but he should've brushed up on his German before filming certain scenes. As an SS soldier drags a boy to an assembly area, he mispronounces the verb "schiessen," which means "to shoot." Instead, he says the verb that means "to defecate."

#8. Citizen Kane
44/RKO Radio Pictures

#8. Citizen Kane

The most famous word ever spoken on film might very well be "rosebud," uttered by Charles Foster Kane (Orson Welles) before he takes his final breath. As reporters scramble to figure out the meaning behind the word, some viewers might wonder how those reporters heard it in the first place, as Kane appeared to be alone when he died. The most ardent fans argue there was a butler in the room, but to this day it remains unclear.

#7. Vertigo
45/Alfred J. Hitchcock Productions

#7. Vertigo

Alfred Hitchcock's epic mystery-thriller is riddled with continuity issues—from Madeline (Kim Novak) losing a shoe in the water and having both on in the next scene, to a sailor walking by the flower shop twice in a row from the same direction. A boom mic is visible in the movie's first scene in Midge's (Barbara Bel Geddes) apartment; and as the camera pans away from Scottie (James Stewart) as he stands at the tower's edge, the camera's shadow appears on the tower's exterior wall (the scene was cropped for the “Alfred Hitchcock Masterpiece Collection” DVD).

#6. Pulp Fiction
46/Miramax

#6. Pulp Fiction

In one of this film's best scenes, a young man emerges from the bathroom and lets the bullets fly toward Vincent (John Travolta) and Jules (Samuel L. Jackson). Before that bathroom door even opens, however, at least two bullet holes are already in the wall.

#5. The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King
47/New Line Cinema

#5. The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King

The third installment of "The Lord of the Rings" trilogy features a truly epic battle scene that required a slew of camera angles and tons of coordination. Because of all the complex camerawork, a number of the film's crew members can be spotted lurking within the orc army. Look for the people who aren't dressed to the nines in battle gear, and who don't resemble evil creatures.

#4. Casablanca
48/Warner Bros.

#4. Casablanca

Inside Rick Blaine's (Humphrey Bogart) Moroccan night club, a now-famous piano player named Sam (Dooley Wilson) sets the atmosphere. Only Wilson didn't actually know how to play the piano. It's no wonder, then, that his hand movements don't match the music whatsoever.

#3. Rear Window
49/Alfred J. Hitchcock Productions

#3. Rear Window

Alfred Hitchcock was a master of suspense, but not necessarily a master of common sense. In this taut thriller, James Stewart's character is a professional photojournalist who is armed with a high-powered camera and a boatload of suspicions about his neighbor (Raymond Burr). And yet he never takes a single photo of the neighbor's potential misdeeds.

#2. 12 Angry Men
50/Orion-Nova Productions

#2. 12 Angry Men

There are 12 angry jurors in this heralded drama, and all but one think the defendant is guilty as charged. The lone holdout is Juror #8 (Henry Fonda), who leaves the room to buy a knife and then introduces new evidence into the proceedings. In real life, these maneuvers would be grounds for a mistrial.

#1. The Godfather
51/Paramount Pictures

#1. The Godfather

The most egregious error in Francis Ford Coppola's 1972 masterpiece comes when Sonny (James Caan) attacks Carlo (Gianni Russo) outside some apartment buildings. In the midst of the beating, Sonny throws a whiff that can be spotted from a mile away, though it's portrayed as a direct hit. It might very well be the most famous "movie" punch in cinematic history.

2018 All rights reserved.