Skip to main content

Main Area

Main

States most affected by government shutdowns

1/
National Parks Conservation Association // Flickr

States most affected by government shutdowns

On January 19, 2018, the United States government shut down for three days when congressional leaders were unable to come to an agreement on the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals program, federal spending, and immigration. For many Americans, the shutdown was a mere annoyance—one more thing for pundits to lament on cable news programs. It was hardly the first time this has happened, after all: the federal government has shut down in the face of a funding gap 18 times before. This time, the government shut down just before Christmas day, after a spending deal could not be reached Dec. 22. This is now the third government shutdown of 2018, and has extended into 2019. 

For those outside of the White House, the shutdown forced their daily lives to grind to a halt. During a shutdown, members of the military stop receiving paychecks until the funding gap is resolved. A lack of staff at the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention makes it difficult for people in need to get flu shots and other public health treatments. Taxpayers may not be able to get the help they need from the IRS, and federal loan applications for small businesses, rural communities, and prospective homeowners are frozen altogether.   

To paint a clearer picture of how government shutdowns affect each state, Stacker referenced WalletHub data collected from the U.S. Census Bureau, U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, usaspending.gov, Fit Small Business, National Association of Realtors, National Park Service and the Kaiser Family Foundation. WalletHub calculated the effect of the government shutdown on six metrics: federal jobs as a share of total state unemployment, federal contract dollars per capita, the percentage of children under the Children's Health Insurance Program, small business lending, real estate as a percentage of the gross state product, and access to national parks. The weighted average of those scores reveals the overall impact of government shutdowns on each state; we've included the number of federal employees in each state as of September 2017 as additional context.

Read on to discover the states where government shutdowns have the biggest impact.

2/
FEMA // Wikicommons

#51. Minnesota

Affected index: 13.31

Federal employees: 32,343

3/
Samantha Appleton // Official White House Photo

#50. Michigan

Affected index: 13.79

Federal employees: 52,617

4/
Senior Airman Jami K. Lancette // U.S. Air Force

#49. Indiana

Affected index: 17.93

Federal employees: 37,913

5/
Senior Airman Aaron J. Jenne // U.S. Air Force

#48. Delaware

Affected index: 19.51

Federal employees: 5,748

6/
Ken LaRock // U.S. Air Force

#47. Ohio

Affected index: 20.64

Federal employees: 78,369

7/
Jack Corn // National Archives and Records Administration // Wikicommons

#46. Tennessee

Affected index: 22.15

Federal employees: 48,873

8/
FEMA // Wikicommons

#45. Iowa

Affected index: 22.92

Federal employees: 17,792

9/
Spc. Ian Withrow, 139th Mobile Public Affairs Detachment // U.S. Army National Guard

#44. Illinois

Affected index: 23.49

Federal employees: 79,588

10/
Wikicommons

#43. North Carolina

Affected index: 24.15

Federal employees: 72,427

11/
FEMA // Wikicommons

#42. North Dakota

Affected index: 24.49

Federal employees: 9,421

12/
Kenneth C. Zirkel // Wikicommons

#41. Vermont

Affected index: 24.92

Federal employees: 6,942

13/
Irving Rusinow // National Archives and Records Administration // Wikicommons

#40. New Hampshire

Affected index: 25.13

Federal employees: 7,617

14/
Akhenaton06 // Wikicommons

#39. South Carolina

Affected index: 25.24

Federal employees: 33,610

15/
Wikicommons

#38. Kansas

Affected index: 25.59

Federal employees: 25,081

16/
Wikicommons

#37. Florida

Affected index: 26.19

Federal employees: 138,913

17/
Wikicommons

#36. Nebraska

Affected index: 26.41

Federal employees: 16,915

18/
FEMA // Wikicommons

#35. Louisiana

Affected index: 26.74

Federal employees: 31,001

19/
Sgt. Katie Eggers // Wisconsin National Guard

#34. Wisconsin

Affected index: 26.78

Federal employees: 29,012

20/
Famartin // Wikicommons

#33. Nevada

Affected index: 27.01

Federal employees: 19,158

21/
Pete Souza // Official White House Photo

#32. New Jersey

Affected index: 27.38

Federal employees: 49,200

22/
STATELIB // Wikicommons

#31. Connecticut

Affected index: 27.62

Federal employees: 18,048

23/
MaxPixel

#30. New York

Affected index: 27.66

Federal employees: 115,407

24/
Daniel Schwen // Wikicommons

#29. Missouri

Affected index: 28.05

Federal employees: 54,542

25/
Daderot // Wikicommons

#28. Kentucky

Affected index: 28.10

Federal employees: 36,598

26/
Robpinion // Wikicommons

#27. Pennsylvania

Affected index: 30.53

Federal employees: 97,125

27/
Bureau of Land Management // Flickr

#26. Oregon

Affected index: 30.58

Federal employees: 29,028

28/
Ken Lund // Flickr

#25. Arkansas

Affected index: 30.86

Federal employees: 19,995

29/
Bureau of Land Management // Wikicommons

#24. Wyoming

Affected index: 31.06

Federal employees: 8,027

30/
FEMA // Wikicommons

#23. Washington

Affected index: 31.57

Federal employees: 75,306

31/
L. D. Andrew // Wikicommons

#22. Georgia

Affected index: 31.74

Federal employees: 100,855

32/
JERRYE AND ROY KLOTZ MD // Wikicommons

#21. South Dakota

Affected index: 32.04

Federal employees: 11,444

33/
Bureau of Land Management // Wikicommons

#20. Utah

Affected index: 32.72

Federal employees: 36,037

34/
Bureau of Land Management

#19. Idaho

Affected index: 32.74

Federal employees: 13,805

35/
Todd Maki // U.S. Air Force

#18. Massachusetts

Affected index: 33.74

Federal employees: 46,138

36/
U.S. Navy // Wikicommons

#17. Arizona

Affected index: 33.84

Federal employees: 56,344

37/
FEMA // Wikicommons

#16. Texas

Affected index: 36.85

Federal employees: 198,851

38/
Kenenth C. Zirkel // Wikicommons

#15. Maine

Affected index: 37.37

Federal employees: 15,396

39/
West Virginia National Guard // Wikicommons

#14. West Virginia

Affected index: 38.22

Federal employees: 23,695

40/
Chuck Kelly // Wikicommons

#13. Mississippi

Affected index: 38.54

Federal employees: 25,332

41/
FEMA // Wikicommons

#12. Rhode Island

Affected index: 39.92

Federal employees: 10,961

42/
U.S. Department of Defense // Wikicommons

#11. Colorado

Affected index: 41.80

Federal employees: 53,974

43/
Wikicommons

#10. Alabama

Affected index: 42.33

Federal employees: 53,066

44/
FEMA // Wikicommons

#9. California

Affected index: 44.37

Federal employees: 248,809

45/
Kelly White // U.S. Air Force

#8. Oklahoma

Affected index: 45.65

Federal employees: 48,009

46/
Senior Master Sgt. Eric Peterson // U.S. Air National Guard photo

#7. Montana

Affected index: 47.96

Federal employees: 13,932

47/
Ken Lund // Flickr

#6. New Mexico

Affected index: 48.87

Federal employees: 29,426

48/
U.S. Navy // Wikicommons

#5. Hawaii

Affected index: 51.86

Federal employees: 33,271

49/
U.S. Coast Guard // Wikicommons

#4. Alaska

Affected index: 58.29

Federal employees: 15,401

50/
Patrick Bloodgood // U.S. Army photo

#3. Virginia

Affected index: 67.67

Federal employees: 177,527

51/
Bestbudbrian // Wikicommons

#2. Maryland

Affected index: 70.41

Federal employees: 146,540

52/
AgnosticPreachersKid // Wikicommons

#1. District of Columbia

Affected index: 70.42

Federal employees: 198,618

2018 All rights reserved.